Skip to Main Content
  • Paul and Jack's Tavern logo top
    Paul and Jack's Tavern logo scroll
  • About
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Catering
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Reserve
  • Events
  • Go to top
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Paul and Jack's Tavern logo topPaul and Jack's Tavern logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • About
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Catering
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Reserve
  • Events

Our Menu

Menu

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Starters

Gourmet Breaded Onion Rings

$10.00
Huge basket of golden fried rings.

Quesadilla

$11.00
Cheese, bacon, and pico de gallo grilled on a wheat tortilla shell, served with salsa and sour cream. Choice of grilled chicken, breaded chicken, steak, or lobster +$2.00

Lobster Nachos

$15.00/+
Fresh-made nacho chips topped with lobster, queso, green onions, diced tomatoes, sliced black olives, and sour cream, served with salsa. Half $10.00 | Full Order $12.00

Toasted Cheese Ravioli

$10.00
Deep fried and served with sauce.
Basket of Fries or Tots photo

Basket of Fries or Tots

$8.00
Fried to perfection. 5 Smothered with chili and cheese.

Clay Street Crab Cakes

$9.00
Two tasty crab cakes. Your choice of cocktail or tartar sauce.

Mozzarella Sticks

$13.00
Served with marinara sauce.

Potato Skins

$13.00
Covered with Cheddar cheese, bacon, green onions, salsa, and sour cream. Add chili & pico de gallo for +$1.50

Jalapeno Bottle Caps

$8.00/+
Beware of the Heat. Battered, deep-fried jalapenos served with ranch. Snack $5.00 | Full Order $7.00

Deep Fried Button Mushrooms

$10.00
Your choice of dipping sauce.

Homemade Hot Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$12.00
Made from scratch served with tortilla chips.

Chips & Salsa

$7.00
Fresh chips and homemade salsa.
Big Kahooky photo

Big Kahooky

$14.00/+
Nacho chips topped with chili meat, green onions, tomatoes, salsa, queso, jalapenos, sour cream and Cheddar cheese. Half $9.00 | Full Order $11.00
Big Screen Sampler photo

Big Screen Sampler

$20.00
Onion rings, mushrooms, ravioli, mozzarella sticks, and chicken tenders. Your choice of sauces (No substitutions).

Homemade Queso Dip

$11.00
Hot cheese dip blended with jalapenos, pico de gallo & spices. Served with tortilla chips. Add chili +$1.00

Spicy Cheese Curds

$11.00
Beware of the HEAT!

Onion Straws

$10.00
Huge Basket of Onion Straw

Mini Tacos

$9.00
Served with our homemade salsa

From the Garden

Dressings: Ranch, Italian, French, Balsamic Vinaigrette, 1000 Island, Blue Cheese, Raspberry Vinaigrette and Honey Mustard.

House photo

House

$7.00
Salad mix topped with shredded cheese, sliced tomatoes, and red onions. Half $7.00 | Full $10.00 | Add your choice of protein: Grilled or Breaded Chicken, Gyro, Salmon, Shrimp or Steak +$5.00
Caesar photo

Caesar

$7.00/+
Romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, croutons, and Parmesan cheese, Half $7.00 | Full $10.00 | Add your choice of protein: Grilled or Breaded Chicken, Gyro, Salmon, Shrimp or Steak +$5.00
Southwest Chicked Salad photo

Southwest Chicked Salad

$14.00
Large green salad, Cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, green onions, mixed with crushed tortilla chips and ranchero dressing, topped with a spicy chicken breast and sour cream.

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$14.00
Large green salad, Cheddar cheese, and diced tomatoes tossed with ranch. Topped with fried or grilled chicken dipped in wing sauce and bleu cheese crumbles.

Chef Salad

$14.00
Bed of lettuce piled high with American, Swiss, and shredded Cheddar cheese, tomatoes, turkey, ham, and sliced onion at your request.

Taco Salad

$14.00
Huge fried tortilla filled with our Chili Meat, lettuce, cheese, diced tomato, sliced jalapeno, green onion, sour cream & ranchero dressing.

Lighter Combos

1/2 Sandwich & Soup or Salad

$12.00
Your choice of our daily soup or Side or Caesar Salad. Choice of 1/2 Sandwich - BLT, Clubhouse, Grilled Cheese, Tuna Salad

Soup And Salad

$11.50
Your choice of our House or Caesar salad and a bowl of our daily soup.

Wraps

Served with your choice of side.

Turkey Bacon Wrap

$15.00
Turkey, bacon, cheese, tomato, lettuce, and ranchero dressing wrapped in a whole wheat tortilla shell.

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$15.00
Wheat tortilla shell coated with blue cheese dressing and spicy wing sauce, filled with fried or grilled chicken, cheese, tomato, and lettuce.

Steak & Cheese Wrap

$15.00
Grilled steak rolled in a wheat tortilla with provolone cheese, lettuce, and PJ sauce. Add Grilled Onions or Mushroom $1.

Caesar Chicken Wrap

$15.00
Grilled chicken rolled in a wheat tortilla shell with romaine lettuce, tossed with caesar dressing and Parmesan cheese. Add Shrimp +$4.00

Seafood Wrap

$16.00
Your choice of Lobster or Shrimp, served with shredded lettuce, tomato & onion wrapped in a flour tortilla shell. Choice of chipotle or fresh lemon mayo dressing. Both Lobster & Shrimp $4.00

Handhelds

Served with your choice of a side.

Clubhouse Sandwich

$14.00
Thinly sliced turkey, ham, and roast beef, American and Swiss cheese, tomatoes, and lettuce on your choice of bread.

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$10.25
White, wheat, or rye bread toasted with American cheese.

Reuben Sandwich

$14.50
Sliced corned beef with melted Swiss cheese, kraut, and thousand island dressing on rye bread.

Country Fried Steak Sandwich

$14.00
1/2 lb breaded and deep fried. Served on a bun.

Northtown Griller

$14.50
Tender roast beef with grilled onions, topped with melted Swiss cheese on a hoagie.
Killer Tenderloin photo

Killer Tenderloin

$14.50
A hand-breaded pork tenderloin on a bun.

Gyro

$14.00
Pita bread filled with grilled seasoned beef strips, feta, lettuce, diced tomatoes and onions, topped with tzatziki cucumber sauce.

Italian Steak Sandwich

$14.50
Scimeca's breaded Italian Steak deep fried topped with sauce and melted cheese on a bun.
French Dip Sandwich photo

French Dip Sandwich

$15.00
Piled high with tender roast beef and provolone cheese on a baguette. Served with au jus.
Super BLT Decker photo

Super BLT Decker

$14.50
Triple-decker piled with bacon, lettuce, and tomato with your choice of bread.

Sal‘s Philly Cheese Steak

$14.50
Thinly sliced steak, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, and topped with melted Swiss.
Cuban Sandwich photo

Cuban Sandwich

$14.50
Pulled pork, ham, dill pickles, Swiss cheese, mustard, and garlic aioli piled on toasted Cuban bread.

World Famous Chili

Same recipe for over 70 years! Add a bag of Fritos to your Chili for +$1.00

Cup of Chili

$6.00
Regular Bowl photo

Regular Bowl

$9.00/+
All meat $11.5 | Add cheddar cheese or onions +$1.00 each
Large Bowl photo

Large Bowl

$11.00/+
All meat $13.50 | Add cheddar cheese or onions +$1.00 each

Chicken Classics

Served with your choice of side.

Chicken Fried Chicken

$14.50
A breaded, deep-fried chicken breast on a bull. Make it Buffalo with a choice of cheese for $15.5

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$14.50
A lightly seasoned, boneless whole chicken breast topped with melted Swiss cheese on a bun.

Grilled BBQ Chicken Sandwich

$15.00
Chicken breast topped wth bacon, Cheddar cheese, and BBQ sauce on a gourmet bun.

Chicken Tenders

$14.50
White meat chicken planks, breaded and deep fried. Choice of honey mustard, BBQ, or ranch dipping sauce.

The Birdie

$14.50
A grilled boneless chicken breast lightly seasoned. Goes great With veggies or baked potato.

Pj's Hot Wing Platter

$14.50
Whole Jumbo wings double dipped our special hot sauce.

Burgers

All burgers served with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions and your choice of a side.

Build Your Own

$12.00/+
1/3 lb hand PATTY $12.00 | 1/2 lb hand PATTY $13.00 | 1 lb hand PATTY $16.00 | Choice of Cheese: American, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Provolone or Cheddar Blue Cheese +$1.00 Crumbles +$1.50 FRIED egg +$1.50 | Choice of Veggies +$1.00 Mushrooms, Jalapeno Peppers, Grilled Onions | Bacon +$1.50

Mini Burger

$7.00
Goes great with a bowl of chili. Add a cup of chili +$6.00

Big Bird Turkey Burger

$13.00
1/2 lb. ground turkey lightly seasoned.

PJ's Double Cheeseburger

$13.00
2 mini burgers, 2 pieces of cheese on a toasted bun

Bogey Burger

$13.00
1/2 lb. burger served BUCK NAKED with sliced tomatoes goes great with a side of cottage cheese.

Bergie Burger

$13.50
1/3 lb. burger topped with a deep-fried onion ring and melted cheese.
Chili Dip Burger photo

Chili Dip Burger

$14.50
1/3 lb. burger served open-faced and topped with chill, Cheddar cheese, diced tomatoes, chopped green onions, and sour cream.
Bleu Bacon Burger photo

Bleu Bacon Burger

$14.50
1/3 lb. burger topped with crispy bacon and bleu cheese crumbles.

From the Sea

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$12.50/+
Our salad is made fresh every day. Make it a Tuna Melt $14.00

Fish & Fries

$15.00
Two hard battered cod filets are deep fried to perfection. No Additional Side

Big Whale Fish Sandwich

$15.50
Our hand-battered cod filets are served on a hoagie.

Grilled Salmon

$16.00
Boneless filet ~ Choice of Cajun, Lemon Pepper or House seasoning or served plain.
Grilled Tilapia Filet photo

Grilled Tilapia Filet

$15.00
Boneless filet Served Cajun, Lemon Pepper, or House Seasoning. Or served plain.

Clay Street Crab Cake Dinner

$14.00
Three crab cakes with your choice of Cocktail, Tartar or PJ Sauce.

Fish Tacos

$14.00
Three soft tacos choice of fried or grilled Cod. Topped with lettuce, cheese & pico de gallo. Served with a side of Ranchero sauce.
Tuna Crown photo

Tuna Crown

$12.50
Whole tomato crown, cut and stuffed with lots of homemade fresh tuna salad. Served with crackers. No side.

Shrimp Basket

$14.50
Large southern-style, hand-breaded shrimp.

Entrees

All Dinner Entrees are served with a choice of salad, potato, and garlic toast. Make your potato loaded +$3.00

KC Strip

$26.00
12 oz. Add sauteed mushrooms +$2.00. Add grilled shrimp +$8.00
Surf & Turf photo

Surf & Turf

$36.00
12 oz. KC Strip & 1/2lb Jumbo Breaded Shrimp

Jumbo Breaded Shrimp Platter

$22.00/+
Served with cocktail sauce. Half pound $22.00 | One pound $32.00

Deep Fried Catfish

$24.00
One pound whole headless that fills the plate. *** Takes 30 minutes to cook

The Country Course

$21.00
Your choice of Country Fried Steak, Chicken Fried Chicken, Or Hand-Breaded Tenderloin served with mashed potatoes & smothered in country gravy.

Hot Spiced Shrimp

$22.00/+
Served with a choice of cocktail sauce, garlic, or lemon bitter. Half Pound $21.00 | Full Pound $31.00

Hot Dogs

We serve only the best "Nathan's" all our dogs are grilled and served with your choice of side. Add Sauerkraut +$1.00

Regular Hot Dog

$9.00

Foot Long Dog

$12.00

DP's 19th Hole Chili Dog

$11.00/+
Grilled hot dog covered with our famous chili, served on a bun. You'll need a knife and fork! Add cheese or onions +$1.00 each | Regular $11.00, Large $14.00

Sides

Fries

$7.00

Tater Tots

$7.00

Sweet Potato Fries

$8.00
Baked Potato photo

Baked Potato

$5.00/+
Cheesy $6.00, Loaded $7.00

Chili Cheese Potato

$8.00

Cottage Cheese

$4.50

Coleslaw

$4.50

Potato Salad

$4.50

Fresh Steamed Veggies

$4.50

Mashed Potato

$6.00
After 4 pm, Brown or White Gravy

Loaded Mashed Potato

$7.00

Cup of Soup

$5.00

Bowl of Soup

$8.00

Pasta

All pasta entrees served with choice of salad and garlic toast.

Chicken Alfredo

$20.00
Penne pasta tossed in Alfredo topped with grilled chicken & Parmesan.
Cajun Pasta photo

Cajun Pasta

$20.00
Cajun-spiced chicken or shrimp on a large bed of Penne Pasta tossed in Alfredo sauce. Topped with diced tomato, green onion, and Parmesan ceese.

Seafood Pasta

$21.00
Grilled shrimp & lobster with Alfredo sauce, Parmesan cheese, and green onion.
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering